We are excited to share that Dossey & Jones now joins the international law firm Withersworldwide!
Our new relationship with Withers offers us the opportunity to better serve our clients and to bring a whole new range of US and international services into play for our clients. We look forward to continuing our work together and to introducing you to our Withers colleagues! Our current address will remain the same, and our phone numbers and email addresses will temporarily remain the same as we work on completing our integration over to Withers.
>> Learn More Here <<

Supreme Court to Address Patent Eligibility of Software -- What Will They Do?

By: Jim Dossey, MS, MBA, JD

The short answer is the Supreme Court will likely issue a narrow opinion specifically ruling on the claims in this case.

The problem is that software is a grey area in US patent law… it is not been directly addressed by either the courts or legislature. Generally, the Court will try to rule narrowly on a particular issue, especially if there is uncertainty in the law. They do not want to be seen as "ruling from the bench"… otherwise they would be usurping the role of the legislature as the rule making body.

A basic principle in patent law is that abstract ideas cannot be the subject of patents. For this reason, a basic software algorithm, like a mathematic algorithm or law of physics, is not patentable. However, if the software is used in a process "carried out with a particular apparatus or else effectuated a transformation of an article from one state to another state or thing", then it may be patentable. Given the arbitrariness of this standard, the USPTO has interpreted the standard broadly and have allowed software patents in a variety of circumstances. I don't think the question at this point is whether software is patentable; the question is what standard the USPTO should use to separate software that is an un-patentable abstract concept from software that should be concretely patentable.


See how Dossey & Jones can help with your intellectual property needs!

Related Posts
  • The Four Categories of Trademarks Read More
  • Confidentiality Agreements: Do's and Don'ts Read More
  • Common Legal Issues Businesses Must Avoid Read More